What fines has the CNIL issued over cookies?

Since 2020, France’s CNIL has issued cookie fines of up to €325 million (Google, 2025), and of a few thousand euros for small businesses. It is one of the most active EU regulators on cookies, so its decisions give a clear picture of what gets fined. Almost all of them point to trackers set before the visitor chose, a rejection harder to express than consent, or cookies that keep running after a rejection. The table below lists the CNIL’s public cookie sanctions, and we update it with each new decision.

Which companies has the CNIL fined over cookies?

The CNIL has published eighteen named decisions since 2020. They are listed from newest to oldest:

Decision date Organisation Fine What was wrong
22 Oct 2026 Fnac Darty (two companies) €7M A tracker set without consent in the mobile app (recommendations, algorithm training)
27 Nov 2025 American Express Carte France €1.5M Trackers before consent, after a rejection and after withdrawal
20 Nov 2025 Les Publications Condé Nast (vanityfair.fr) €750,000 Cookies before any choice and after a rejection
1 Sept 2025 Google LLC and Google Ireland €325M Ads inserted between Gmail emails, cookies set when the account is created
1 Sept 2025 Shein (Infinite Styles Services) €150M Cookies before any choice, rejection and withdrawal that did not work
14 Nov 2024 Orange €50M Mainly ads inserted between emails, and cookies
29 Dec 2023 Yahoo EMEA €10M Cookies despite a rejection; withdrawing consent cut off access to the mailbox
15 June 2023 Criteo €40M Unable to prove people’s consent (GDPR), plus other breaches
29 Dec 2022 Apple Distribution International €8M Advertising identifier read without consent
29 Dec 2022 TikTok €5M Rejecting harder than accepting, insufficient information
29 Dec 2022 Voodoo €3M Advertising identifier used without consent
19 Dec 2022 Microsoft Ireland (bing.com) €60M Rejecting harder than accepting, advertising cookies without consent
31 Dec 2021 Google €150M Rejecting harder than accepting
31 Dec 2021 Facebook €60M Rejecting harder than accepting
27 July 2021 Société du Figaro €50,000 Partners’ cookies set without consent
7 Dec 2020 Google LLC and Google Ireland €100M Advertising cookies without consent, insufficient information
7 Dec 2020 Amazon Europe Core €35M Advertising cookies without consent, insufficient information
18 Nov 2020 Carrefour France and Carrefour Banque €2.25M and €800,000 Cookies among other GDPR breaches

The CNIL’s register also lists anonymised sanctions:

  • a mail-order furniture retailer (€600,000, July 2025);
  • a distance seller (€500,000, November 2025);
  • an app publisher (€270,000, December 2025);
  • a services company (€3.5M, December 2025);
  • around fifteen simplified fines of €2,000 to €20,000 since 2024.

In 2025, the CNIL issued 83 sanctions totalling €486.8 million. 21 organisations were fined over trackers.

What does the CNIL hold against them?

The most frequent complaint is trackers that fire before the visitor has chosen. It is the first thing the CNIL checks: it opens the site without clicking anything and looks at what is already set. Shein, American Express, Condé Nast and Fnac Darty were all fined for this.

Next comes a rejection harder than consent. In 2021 and 2022, Google, Facebook, Microsoft and TikTok offered an immediate “Accept all” button, while rejecting took several clicks. Since then, regulators expect a “Reject all” at the same level, as our guide does your website need a cookie banner? explains.

At American Express and Condé Nast, the banner existed, but trackers fired despite the rejection, for example when a tool had been added without going through the banner.

Mobile apps follow the same rule: the decisions against Apple, Voodoo and Fnac Darty concern identifiers read in an app. Finally, Criteo was not fined for a badly set cookie, but because it could not prove that people had consented. Keeping a record of each choice is part of the obligation.

What does a small site risk?

Most CNIL sanctions go through the simplified procedure, reserved for simple cases: 67 out of 83 in 2025. The fine is capped at €20,000, with a daily penalty of at most €100. Since 28 May 2026, the cap rises to €100,000 (and €500 a day) for organisations with a worldwide turnover above €50 million. These decisions are not published under the organisation’s name. The ordinary procedure, mostly aimed at large groups, goes up to €10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover for a cookie breach.

In July 2026, the CNIL announced 23 more simplified sanctions since January, on all topics, totalling €133,750.

Other regulators have their own procedures and amounts, but the points they check are the same, because they apply the same ePrivacy Directive and GDPR.

Check your site before a regulator does

The simplest is to repeat what the CNIL does. Open your site in a private window, without clicking anything, and look at the cookies set. Then click “Reject all” and reload. The Nodbar scan runs exactly these two tests and lists what fires when it should not, with the service responsible. To understand which trackers can stay, read our guide to cookies exempt from consent.

FAQ

What is the maximum fine for cookies in France?

For a breach of the French cookie rule (Article 82 of the Data Protection Act, which transposes the ePrivacy Directive), €10 million or 2% of worldwide turnover, whichever is higher. That ceiling is what allows fines of over €100 million against large groups. Other EU countries set their own ceilings for ePrivacy breaches; GDPR breaches go up to €20 million or 4%.

Is a fine preceded by a warning?

Often, the CNIL first sends a formal notice with a deadline to comply. It is not required to: it can fine directly, and some decisions add a penalty for each day of delay.

Does this apply to your site?

Paste its address: Nodbar visits it like a first-time visitor, records what fires before consent and prepares a compliant banner. Free, no sign-up needed for the scan.